Edward "Ed" Esposito is vice-president, information media for the Rubber City Radio Group. He oversees news and public affairs programs for www.AkronNewsNow.com, 1590 WAKR, 97.5 WONE and 94.9 WQMX. He is Secretary-Treasurer of the Radio Television Digital News Foundation; a former chair of the Radio Television Digital News Association and Foundation and a former president of the Ohio Associated Press Broadcasters Association. He's also served as a member of the Akron Press Club , Kent State University Student Media Advisory Board, Ohio Open Government Coalition, Northeast Ohio AMBER Task Force. He's lectured on broadcasting and journalism for the University of Missouri in China, as well as across the country for RTDNA and RTDNF. You can reach Ed through the newsroom at 330-864-6397 or by email email@example.com
The decisions by the Summit County Board of Elections regarding independents running for public office are taking a beating from Ohio's Supreme Court.
On top of a decision ordering former Republican State Senator Kevin Coughlin back on the ballot for Stow Muni Clerk of Courts, the county board has also been ordered to return Darrita Davis to the November 5th ballot in her ward council bid.
On a 4-3 decision the state's highest court ruled basing the decision to disqualify Davis because she voted Democrat in the last Presidential Election Primary wasn't enough to overrule her candidacy as an independent.
- - -
(Supreme Court of Ohio) In an expedited election case announced today, the Supreme Court of Ohio ordered the Summit County Board of Elections to include Darrita Davis on the November 5 ballot as an independent candidate for Akron City Council.
The court, in a 4-3 decision, granted Davis’s writ, finding that the board of elections abused its discretion when it disqualified her petition to run as an independent.
The elections board argued that Davis is not an independent because she failed to disaffiliate sufficiently from the Democratic Party. The court today said that the board based its conclusion on only one piece of information – her vote in the Democratic primary for president in March 2012.
“A candidate’s prior voting history, standing alone, cannot be a sufficient basis for disqualifying an independent candidate,” the court wrote. “Disaffiliation by definition presumes a history of support for or membership in a political party. If a candidate’s prior voting record, standing alone, could trump a declaration of disaffiliation, then disaffiliation would never be possible.”
The court also said the board erroneously applied a two-year statutory look-back provision for petition signatures to the separate analysis of disaffiliation under R.C. 3513.257: “The practical effect of the board’s rule is the creation of a de facto ‘sit out’ requirement, whereby candidates who disaffiliate from a political party have to wait at least two years before they may seek office as independents. Nothing in R.C. 3513.257 requires such a result.”
The court found that two donations Davis made to Democratic candidates at different events held little weight, primarily because the donations were made before she declared her candidacy for city council in July 2013. While evidence undermining disaffiliation after a candidate files is not required for a successful challenge to a candidate’s petition, “where the challenge is based solely on prepetition evidence, the evidence needs to be that much more substantial to warrant excluding an otherwise qualified candidate,” the court stated.
“In addition, the board abused its discretion because it fundamentally misconstrued the relevant inquiry,” the court found. “Based on her past voting record, the board informs the court, ‘the Board determined that Relator did not make a good faith attempt to disaffiliate from the Democratic Party.’ But the requirement … is that a candidate must declare her lack of affiliation in good faith, not that she take affirmative action to disaffiliate in order to prove her good faith. In other words, the declaration of disaffiliation can, in some circumstances, be sufficient affirmative action.”
The per curiam (not authored by a specific justice) opinion was joined by Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor and Justices Paul E. Pfeifer, Sharon L. Kennedy, and William M. O’Neill. Justice Terrence O’Donnell dissented in a written opinion. Justice Judith Ann Lanzinger also dissented, but wrote separately. Justice Judith L. French dissented without opinion.
In his dissent, Justice O’Donnell wrote: “In view of Davis’s voting history and her financial contributions to Democratic candidates in April 2013 and June 2013, the board did not abuse its discretion in concluding that Davis had not in good faith disaffiliated herself from the Democratic Party when she filed her nominating petition to run as an independent candidate.”
In her separate dissent, Justice Lanzinger wrote: “The county boards of elections are given little guidance when asked to determine whether an independent candidate has made a good-faith declaration of disaffiliation. … Because I believe that the Summit County Board of Elections did not act unreasonably under the circumstances, I would deny the writ.”
A state discipline board says Akron Municipal Court Judge Joy Malek Oldfield should be publicly reprimanded for not taking herself off cases involving a public defender she was found in a parked car with in Copley last year.
But the board found inconclusive evidence as to whether Oldfield was engaging in sexual activity with Catherine Loya. It also ruled Oldfield didn't use her title to try to stop police from arresting Loya after they smelled alcohol on her breath.
Loya was eventually moved out of Oldfield's courtroom, but not before Oldfield handled 53 pleas involving Loya's clients.
The Ohio Supreme Court will make a final decision.
UPDATE 9:11 p.m. Police cancelled the Missing Adult Alert for Emmett Hilton, 87, last seen in Olmsted Township. No other details are available.
Earlier coverage: A Missing Adult Alert has been issued by the Olmsted Township Police Department for the following regions: North Central Ohio, Central & East Lakeshore, Northwest Ohio, which includes the following counties: Ashland, Ashtabula, Crawford, Cuyahoga, Defiance, Erie, Fulton, Geauga, Henry, Huron, Knox, Lake, Lorain, Lucas, Marion, Medina, Morrow, Ottawa, Richland, Sandusky, Seneca, Williams, Wood, and Wyandot.
Information as of: October 17, 2013 at 6:18 PM
Be on the lookout for a missing adult. On October 16, 2013 at 5:00 AM, Mr. Hilton was last seen at his residence.
The incident took place in Cuyahoga County, OH on Lewis Road in the city of Olmsted Township 44138.
The adult's name is Emmett Hilton and the individual is missing. The adult is a White male, age 87, is 5' 9" tall, weighs 143 lbs., has brown hair, and has brown eyes. Mr. Hilton suffers from confusion and early stages of Dementia. He was last seen headed westbound on Route 20 after he stopped at some one's residence in Huron County on October 17, 2013 at 3:00 PM inquiring to see his wife, who resides at a nursing home. Mr. Hilton was confused and left before local law enforcement arrived.
The vehicle involved is a silver 2002 Toyota Rav4 with OH plate number LTH3.
Call or dial 911 if you see the adult or the vehicle. You can also call 1-866-693-9171 to be transferred directly to the investigating law enforcement agency or to hear the alert information.
Summit County Children's Services have a final pick to serve as their new Executive Director when John Saros steps down at the end of the year.
Julie Barnes runs Stark County's Jobs and Family Services department, a job she's held since June 2008. Barnes is a veteran of Summit County's CSB, working here as director of foster care and adoption programs from 2002 to 2007.
Talks are continuing on a contract and start date.
- - -
(Summit County CSB) After a search which lasted several months, the search committee of the Board of Trustees of Summit County Children Services (SCCS) announced today its recommendation of the top finalist to succeed John Saros who is retiring as SCCS Executive Director at the end of 2013. The top finalist is Julie Barnes, M.Ed., LSW, who is presently Executive Director of Stark County Job and Family Services (SCJFS), a triple-combined agency including Human Services, Child Support and Children Services with approximately 475 staff and an annual budget of approximately $50 million.
Ms. Barnes has held her current position since June 2008 after serving as Deputy Director of Children Services from May, 2007-May 2008. Prior to joining SCJFS, Ms. Barnes served as Director of Foster Care and Adoption at Summit County Children Services from February 2002-May 2007. Ms. Barnes has also gained experience in the child welfare field through earlier positions at the Ohio Department of Job And Family Services and Geauga County Department of Job and Family Services. Ms. Barnes has a B.A. Degree in Psychology from Hiram College and a M.Ed. Degree in Higher Education from Kent State University.
A start date and an employment agreement have yet to be finalized.
Ms. Barnes will be introduced to the community at a reception at Summit County Children Services scheduled for Wednesday, October 30 from 4-6 p.m.
It's a repeat of the Radio Roundup for some of the Akron-area's best food trucks! Food Truck Friday happens this Friday, October 18 from 11:00 a.m. until 1:00 p.m. or the food runs out.
Participating food trucks making a return to the Akron Radio Center include Stone Pelican Rolling Cafe; Wholly Frijoles Mexican Street Food; Mobile Sushi Bar and Get Stuffed! New to the mix are the Swenson's mobile truck; Vaccaro's mobile wood-fired pizza oven and Pig Lickin' Good BBQ. The food truck operators come from the greater Akron area with locations including Summit and Medina Counties.
The first Food Truck Friday in August drew hundreds of hungry people to the Akron Radio Center, 1795 West Market Street, to sample some of the offerings from the food trucks which aren't allowed to do business on Akron city streets due to restrictions banning street sales.
Akron City Council set up a special committee to review the issue and the debate has often been framed in terms of protecting brick-and-mortar businesses such as established restaurants versus the restraint of commerce from the entrepreneurial food truck operators. While the committee hasn't met many times over the summer since the issue first arose, chair Jeff Fusco, Akron City Council at-large, told WAKR's Ray Horner they were still reviewing information from other cities where food trucks are already operating.
Criminal indictments handed down today by a Federal grand jury over campaign donations collected by Canton's Benjamin Suarez and his company's chief financial officer, Michael Giorgio.
In addition to charges relating to illegal use of corporate money in support of political campaigns, conspiracy and obstruction of justice for political cash worth at least $100,000 dollars in 2012.
The indictment charges the men used their position to get company workers to write campaign donations which would be repaid by the company.
Suarez is a major contributor to mostly Republican candidates; while neither candidate is specifically named in the indictments he supported both Wadsworth Congressman Jim Renacci and Ohio Treasurer Josh Mandel, who sought to unseat incumbent U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown.
A copy of the indictment is listed in the attachment section at the bottom of this story.
On this election day, you should exercise your rights and duty as a citizen and vote for the men and women who put their reputations on the line to represent all of us.
Even when they make it tough.
Akron in particular seems to bring out the absolute worst in the political personality. Mayor Plusquellic waltzed in to radio stations (including WAKR and WONE, owned by the same company that owns AkronNewsNow.com) just before the weekend with check in hand. He bought what can easily be termed hard-hitting commercials where he targets at-large candidate Bruce Kilby, repeating charges that have been around for decades and unearthing a clip from a City Council verbal scuffle where Kilby accused Council of being for sale.
To say the charges -- including breaking a teen's wrist and hitting a woman -- are old chestnuts would be repeating old news. The Mayor's been launching those points against Kilby for at least the last 15 years. As to the "Council for sale" audio clips, those come from the late 1990's when then-councilman Ernie Tarle was popped for passing cash underneath a restroom stall in City Hall. Same old same old, including Kilby's vehement denials and counter-charges the Mayor is lying.
Akron voters can be excused for thinking they've heard all this before.They have. Again. And again. And again. It's the drum that keeps on banging. Both sides must figure if they say it enough times then everyone will just assume it's a fact.
The problem with that strategy -- and the critics of the Mayor are just as bad, with often-repeated rumors of bad behavior that turn out to be false -- is that voters these days don't spend the time to figure out if it's true or not. The media won't spend the time on these cry-wolf stories when they come up again and again for the same reason. It just becomes noise. It's just the loud background sound from the demolition of the capacity to take politicians seriously.
It's not just Akron city politics; it's typical of the occasional feuds between regional politicians. It's a hallmark of the discourse that surrounds presidents and presidential candidates to the point where the White House looks like a mud hut by the time they're done. It'll be what we see when the statewide races get underway in 2014 with both candidates running for governor likely to call each other crooks, scoundrels and liars -- all while voters go about their everyday lives and slowly but surely turn the noise down until it's time to vote.
Or when it's time to ignore the process altogether and let the drama queens have at it in a room with nobody watching.
Ohio's Supreme Court administered a unanimous comeuppance to Summit County's Board of Elections and ordered to put former State Senator Kevin Coughlin on the November ballot for Stow Municipal Court Clerk.
Coughlin took the Board to court after it rejected his candidacy on the grounds prior races as a Republican made him ineligible for a non-partisan position. The Court ruled there's no regulation barring those with a partisan history from running for a non-partisan job.
- - -
(Kevin Coughlin) In a unanimous decision, the Ohio Supreme Court today issued an order to compel the Summit County Board of Elections to place former State Senator Kevin Coughlin on the November ballot as a candidate for Stow Municipal Clerk of Courts.
On July 15, the Summit County Board of Elections rejected Coughlin's nominating petitions to run for the office based on its position that Coughlin's history as a Republican disqualifies him from running as a non-partisan. Ohio law, however, authorizes non-partisan candidacies for municipal judges and clerks of court. Candidates who seek to be nominated as non-partisans are not required to be unaffiliated with a political party.
The Court's decision overturns the Board's action. Coughlin issued the following statement:
"I'm grateful to the Ohio Supreme Court for upholding my right to run.
"The party bosses in Summit County disregarded the law and tried to silence me because I am running to modernize our court. That means ending their influence in the clerk's office. Now nothing can stop the voters from having a chance to elect someone who will run this nonpartisan judicial office as a professional.
"If it was the intention of the bosses to slow my campaign down, they failed. We have been campaigning hard all throughout the court district and I'm encouraged by the support we have received including the endorsements of several Republican and Democratic community leaders.
"The judges of the Stow Municipal Court have been doing an excellent job. I'm looking forward to working with them to fix our broken clerk's office and better serve our communities."